{
  "problem": "A saturated sand column drains through its base: the top desaturates, pore pressure falls below zero and the column settles under the Bishop effective stress and its lighter weight, as in the Liakopoulos experiment. No closed form exists; an independent solver of the same continuum supplies the reference.",
  "result": "Largest nodal pressure error on the 0.0125 m mesh with 480 steps at 5, 20, 60 and 120 min: 0.14 / 0.02 / 0.02 / 0.01% of $\\rho_fgH$; settlement 0.24 / 0.05 / 0.02 / 0.01%. With 960 steps: 0.07 / 0.02 / 0.01 / 0.01% and 0.12 / 0.03 / 0.01 / 0.01%.",
  "scope": "2D, PT, 480 steps; pressure errors on meshes 0.05 m: 0.58 / 0.34 / 0.22 / 0.16%; 0.025 m: 0.17 / 0.09 / 0.06 / 0.04%; 0.0125 m: 0.14 / 0.02 / 0.02 / 0.01%. Late-time pressure converges at about second order with the mesh; the first frame and the settlement are limited by the step, since the base opens at once and the sequential coupling lags one step. The explicit strain form on the 0.05 m mesh gives 0.55 / 0.33 / 0.21 / 0.16% and settlement 0.01 / 0.01 / 0.00 / 0.00%. 3D is queued for a larger machine. Reference: 200 cells, BDF; grid differences fall at second order. (a) pressure profiles; (b) settlement history, DES saved every 5 min; (c) pressure error: circles 480 steps, diamonds 960 steps, open squares the explicit form.",
  "meaning": "This checks Richards flow and the Bishop coupling together during drainage: desaturation, suction, the effective-stress change and the lighter weight of the drying column.",
  "metric": 0.0007289644671352397,
  "metric_label": "pressure error",
  "spacing_m": 0.0125,
  "evidence": {
    "executable_sha256": "464d02daa7ffc3594f86a751118c05561bc257764ead83a2046a4c640f0a3bfe",
    "reproduction_revision": "3774df00ba1708a4f70a836d2073f845653aac64",
    "reference": [
      {
        "time": 300.0,
        "settlement": -0.0017899037326765327,
        "p_top": -831.2158315825735,
        "saturation_top": 0.962938756759877
      },
      {
        "time": 1200.0,
        "settlement": -0.0018855175924843968,
        "p_top": -1482.1194189028097,
        "saturation_top": 0.9061883936686043
      },
      {
        "time": 3600.0,
        "settlement": -0.0019904700990222212,
        "p_top": -2143.105926049031,
        "saturation_top": 0.8416007763677477
      },
      {
        "time": 7200.0,
        "settlement": -0.0020712143780150663,
        "p_top": -2661.758283684402,
        "saturation_top": 0.7920156834415361
      }
    ],
    "cases": [
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.05,
        "mode": "PT",
        "steps": 480,
        "frames": [
          {
            "time": 300.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.005753476683894621,
            "settlement": -0.001785530551335041,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0017899037326765327,
            "settlement_error": 0.002443249467362296,
            "p_min": -805.579060214317
          },
          {
            "time": 1200.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.003360091817912212,
            "settlement": -0.0018844190651135656,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0018855175924843968,
            "settlement_error": 0.0005826131642631127,
            "p_min": -1469.8790598732223
          },
          {
            "time": 3600.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.0021551457565487653,
            "settlement": -0.001989932627799085,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0019904700990222212,
            "settlement_error": 0.0002700222542404429,
            "p_min": -2138.137820596111
          },
          {
            "time": 7200.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.0015920458872410708,
            "settlement": -0.0020709619723202296,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0020712143780150663,
            "settlement_error": 0.00012186362624544422,
            "p_min": -2660.3297955354146
          }
        ],
        "pressure_error": 0.005753476683894621,
        "settlement_error": 0.002443249467362296,
        "input_sha256": "8a4fa7a2c4d24c8846d00b5c289839e1c27afeb3dac685dc7e5b4e3d81a0f305"
      },
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.025,
        "mode": "PT",
        "steps": 480,
        "frames": [
          {
            "time": 300.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.001661836935442265,
            "settlement": -0.001785589501624907,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0017899037326765327,
            "settlement_error": 0.002410314573272898,
            "p_min": -823.2639245591146
          },
          {
            "time": 1200.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.0008675276217199423,
            "settlement": -0.001884502051944418,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0018855175924843968,
            "settlement_error": 0.0005386004055473181,
            "p_min": -1479.3055360713472
          },
          {
            "time": 3600.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.0005567864938331749,
            "settlement": -0.0019899927209039102,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0019904700990222212,
            "settlement_error": 0.00023983184602749397,
            "p_min": -2142.187147330518
          },
          {
            "time": 7200.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.00041540112369149046,
            "settlement": -0.0020709651608418474,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0020712143780150663,
            "settlement_error": 0.00012032418076290963,
            "p_min": -2661.6898502711706
          }
        ],
        "pressure_error": 0.001661836935442265,
        "settlement_error": 0.002410314573272898,
        "input_sha256": "7abeae7905345b1293233c7b22400c10d90deb93dc3f938ba9fcdc9d6a086a54"
      },
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.0125,
        "mode": "PT",
        "steps": 480,
        "frames": [
          {
            "time": 300.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.0014244488443121116,
            "settlement": -0.0017856493039161694,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0017899037326765327,
            "settlement_error": 0.0023769036751498662,
            "p_min": -827.8015688670885
          },
          {
            "time": 1200.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.00023527395917690702,
            "settlement": -0.0018845224806106394,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0018855175924843968,
            "settlement_error": 0.000527765891829346,
            "p_min": -1481.3473196452182
          },
          {
            "time": 3600.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.0001551193831291446,
            "settlement": -0.001989999301146102,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0019904700990222212,
            "settlement_error": 0.00023652597260837016,
            "p_min": -2142.9063120557416
          },
          {
            "time": 7200.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.0001207384439912598,
            "settlement": -0.002070955339779011,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0020712143780150663,
            "settlement_error": 0.00012506587382010714,
            "p_min": -2661.776282283981
          }
        ],
        "pressure_error": 0.0014244488443121116,
        "settlement_error": 0.0023769036751498662,
        "input_sha256": "35fbda82e6813d7acaa372243389ed3e32bf6b3533422614cb435450e114eac2"
      }
    ],
    "refined": {
      "spacing_m": 0.0125,
      "mode": "PT",
      "steps": 960,
      "frames": [
        {
          "time": 300.0,
          "pressure_error": 0.0007289644671352397,
          "settlement": -0.0017878222467469054,
          "settlement_ref": -0.0017899037326765327,
          "settlement_error": 0.0011629038431664185,
          "p_min": -829.1338240179224
        },
        {
          "time": 1200.0,
          "pressure_error": 0.00021223247754579728,
          "settlement": -0.0018850211449893302,
          "settlement_ref": -0.0018855175924843968,
          "settlement_error": 0.00026329507454370127,
          "p_min": -1481.574704341392
        },
        {
          "time": 3600.0,
          "pressure_error": 0.0001470637996964174,
          "settlement": -0.0019902356346814076,
          "settlement_ref": -0.0019904700990222212,
          "settlement_error": 0.00011779345036577737,
          "p_min": -2142.9855173490823
        },
        {
          "time": 7200.0,
          "pressure_error": 0.00011642687243208339,
          "settlement": -0.002071087152958886,
          "settlement_ref": -0.0020712143780150663,
          "settlement_error": 6.142534424768975e-05,
          "p_min": -2661.818634451976
        }
      ],
      "pressure_error": 0.0007289644671352397,
      "settlement_error": 0.0011629038431664185,
      "input_sha256": "a41cebed6f88337d802c6e7a3ca1166051718f9717384601a6b82a5bb59807f9"
    },
    "explicit": [
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.05,
        "mode": "explicit",
        "steps": 0,
        "frames": [
          {
            "time": 300.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.005544567766380575,
            "settlement": -0.0017900050899265375,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0017899037326765327,
            "settlement_error": 5.662720746046901e-05,
            "p_min": -807.3487674246734
          },
          {
            "time": 1200.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.003329249710208235,
            "settlement": -0.0018853845037058602,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0018855175924843968,
            "settlement_error": 7.058474504140211e-05,
            "p_min": -1470.1538919011648
          },
          {
            "time": 3600.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.0021452078577952343,
            "settlement": -0.001990391021292569,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0019904700990222212,
            "settlement_error": 3.9728167577579576e-05,
            "p_min": -2138.2274914585105
          },
          {
            "time": 7200.0,
            "pressure_error": 0.0015867950605077013,
            "settlement": -0.0020712191368804696,
            "settlement_ref": -0.0020712143780150663,
            "settlement_error": 2.2976208806646525e-06,
            "p_min": -2660.376910455919
          }
        ],
        "pressure_error": 0.005544567766380575,
        "settlement_error": 7.058474504140211e-05,
        "input_sha256": "3ff0b9e6232dcd35b5b537785fb5785ff5a1312f3646bb4cbc3d828d6876029d"
      }
    ],
    "sanity_3d": null
  }
}
