{
  "problem": "A circular tunnel is excavated in rock under uniform in-situ stress: the support pressure on its wall is lowered to zero, and a ring of rock around the opening yields. Salençon’s solution gives the stresses, the plastic radius and the wall convergence for a perfectly plastic Mohr–Coulomb material.",
  "result": "On the 0.05 m mesh the hoop stress is within 1.57% of $P$ (RMS), the displacement within 0.21% of the wall convergence, and the plastic radius within 0.34%. The radial strain error, 3.88% of $P/G$, is concentrated within half a radius of the wall.",
  "scope": "2D plane strain, perfect Mohr–Coulomb, dilation 30°; 16 unloading steps with mixed stress; inner spacings 0.2, 0.1, 0.05 m. (a) stresses; (b) tunnel convergence; (c) mesh convergence.",
  "meaning": "This checks Mohr–Coulomb plasticity with dilation around an opening: the stress redistribution, the extent of the plastic zone and the wall convergence that support design relies on.",
  "metric": 0.015669343621469076,
  "metric_label": "hoop stress RMS / P",
  "spacing_m": 0.05,
  "evidence": {
    "executable": "benchmarks/hydromechanics/results/runs/shear-cap-20261108/candidate/dynearthsol2d",
    "executable_sha256": "d26cc84f43d8a0cbd06017160e47add950f012ff885db1c8ecbbd46b79b262ff",
    "solver_commit": null,
    "source_sha256": {
      "check_salencon.py": "d990f80ba694f7f489686bf646b6a3a34b563b92710a6d1cf34b8926647154c6",
      "check_kirsch.py": "33e439ffe61786a855a66c1f498c374d30bbb7722ea4dfeed2e279db02183869",
      "salencon_reference.py": "1d7dde83664a65b982bd11affd87d789342f12c485601707b3835cd797753d97"
    },
    "PT_option": 1,
    "PT_CFL": 0.25,
    "mixed_stress": true,
    "load_steps": 16,
    "refined_radius_m": 3.0,
    "reference": {
      "opening_radius_m": 1.0,
      "outer_radius_m": 20.0,
      "pressure_Pa": 500000.0,
      "cohesion_Pa": 100000.0,
      "friction_degrees": 30.0,
      "dilation_degrees": 30.0,
      "bulk_modulus_Pa": 21666666666.666668,
      "shear_modulus_Pa": 10000000000.0,
      "finite_plastic_radius_m": 1.395750563538275,
      "infinite_plastic_radius_m": 1.3940500970101701
    },
    "cases": [
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.2,
        "folder": "../mixed-graded-h0.2/h0.2",
        "nodes": 712,
        "elements": 1321,
        "errors": {
          "radial_stress_rms": 0.019664543338025916,
          "hoop_stress_rms": 0.08827516505703524,
          "out_of_plane_rms": 0.03284430074858925,
          "radial_strain_rms": 0.180236988091484,
          "hoop_strain_rms": 0.09931640919921782,
          "shear_stress_rms": 0.0293878314275552,
          "displacement_rms_over_wall": 0.026553332068834052,
          "displacement_max_over_wall": 0.19406686913929413,
          "plastic_radius_relative": 0.04227766530778654
        },
        "yield_admissibility": {
          "elements": 592,
          "outside_yield": 17,
          "min_slack_Pa": -182893.01637444942,
          "max_violation_over_P": 0.3657860327488988
        },
        "max_free_force_over_PR": 9.386616926253065e-08,
        "accepted_max_force_over_PR": 8.892690330522903e-14,
        "plastic_radius_m": 1.3367414883598494,
        "reference_plastic_radius_m": 1.395750563538275,
        "reference_wall_displacement_m": -5.3801959740366954e-05,
        "maximum_abs_strain": 0.00019729277135127935,
        "inputs_sha256": {
          "annulus.poly": "8d17b4fbf6968c4bcc6d5db43d770713e46fce0984fd761a9ff93d2b85955fcc",
          "load-001.cfg": "c0675d4c19910c46d2b3f27a38ddf69b362e25f06b3f9c5be22074250efc3f5a",
          "load-002.cfg": "85208392231a0a8e4dbff27ab4256e127932b74b67d8e521eab3fdbb3b7d6e73",
          "load-003.cfg": "6145b79d463cd12e8e786a8fef5e9ee89d91ca6345259047f5e80fbca52797a0",
          "load-004.cfg": "97dccfc80261310d2891c85462edabac0faf5e269c3b0d9f9048f768547aa9d0",
          "load-005.cfg": "f1ddc4f8908907b97e395c819e6dac8060ecfcbb35f7f73581b004a9ca6dc755",
          "load-006.cfg": "0ac4c377cb48fd7deec1f82726265d6edb37ddf3bdb53bd68a7c28f8464e8d7d",
          "load-007.cfg": "4dda0d7060d53e0ce97ff83143d8bb51d1510eae51d26b1667dfb5fade6788dc",
          "load-008.cfg": "949d92508cdb36e2291da5ee7e01bf7add81b10412e25844e895b4b87cae4e01",
          "load-009.cfg": "d8e6b7ec0fdbdfe2cd3f4b420f3063aa3bd9d05d6a036d8c6d1182c406a8561e",
          "load-010.cfg": "bbcaa3a8e2ddf6e8f80d976476ccdcf7c5a971e53a5e5b343a2d944d4eb2ea43",
          "load-011.cfg": "5cc4ee45e32abcaa0b2d3f5960cf558ab131f196f356afe64860ca275e664ccc",
          "load-012.cfg": "0af67038edc509bb91f62a5b720432586d6bd39c8468e258692a86ee4e53a7eb",
          "load-013.cfg": "66724c3003116d97276a3429355dd42a59912ca3a5a2f47e24c4544aa25a2e95",
          "load-014.cfg": "125a2bf3c92dd383b40a3af1a8d56eff14a9a68571408d18b23a9b4b65dc1846",
          "load-015.cfg": "7d83c858a86daad4845e15fe2b324dd1093e1ed461257455c89c1dd6773851c9",
          "load-path.json": "a5ae765cc4a19eb48c0753379221d15125cea1b5a01d97bd71c9d8606c1c8e96",
          "salencon.cfg": "4960c6939f0bf104157fe2362435c6af9ac286d57cfbf79ff60ed9f60d3a25eb",
          "seed.cfg": "0b8ff9e4e69da22276d846ebd73a30500b3f2f9d4b79cfb2a192f930692a1cf0"
        },
        "outputs_sha256": {
          "load-001.chkpt.000001": "476df89e116a8c549387f175f966713f6116ad1e0856431050d05bbd452a3413",
          "load-001.info": "bddd3013fd9fab6a68afb5849d985f87477ee1be67c6fc2b6bbc76957dc48957",
          "load-001.save.000000": "5ea50f325f41f9d58b2cfc371a296dd1ff8d4090354dba0951e0d6cb7dd68a9a",
          "load-001.save.000001": "810053ede13912dcb9a9a261a29248f568e5b8cfd37d5069a75eb9e5984f8f52",
          "load-002.chkpt.000002": "0b2a198271c9340e2239eecb8ec003e0ba33bf0e82390bbf418517fb462dd118",
          "load-002.info": "c12ef9852de4ef550f89e1412851a5c0c2c27d58e549b798338b58fa565d17f8",
          "load-002.save.000001": "42894590171ffadf3ef25f370d3b524c95c8292d79b662b6a73810c755fa300d",
          "load-002.save.000002": "5e9dc52ee75ef014131559144f73973100a5ee925950956c05f57d97def1873c",
          "load-003.chkpt.000003": "823c9f1e5377ac02d3bb73087c131d657e5db609c9e8cc70429aa036c65fbe2a",
          "load-003.info": "949f6704354fc2167d74a82c8dcc37e46f79e76f0b6b526c7ebf07478d3ab6f7",
          "load-003.save.000002": "668cde61915210bd6b96813718fd9614cfd9aa55c1317477b574c98e5e3d389b",
          "load-003.save.000003": "40251c69875ba7f2ed804d5ef4d493b3039a1a6a161fce0c656a892467535820",
          "load-004.chkpt.000004": "1ec0079a65b09b8b4ae5cf0789e84a5afc23979281980c7a3738cac0fda2ae7a",
          "load-004.info": "5b31f680607fc1a73ad8f2630ca2fd5e2207e4f510f9f880f7b5284a621feee1",
          "load-004.save.000003": "3d2c2079937c89efd33031f80535f5492603691075f6014176e23b234b2813df",
          "load-004.save.000004": "2407e5b3ab067c44802ae320adfeba0721a875cc016da034912bd590420b44cb",
          "load-005.chkpt.000005": "bb3f4f0f5926d25d559dcea12e39f505afe18abb7ef27c71e349a02a059291f3",
          "load-005.info": "098926a9a4926c39e940e0247ce2469c8b313453d12d0c65812bc996761eda27",
          "load-005.save.000004": "e977b2d9421f1233d9b899c3c33d79563b8160ab5b24c72bed99efbf3753bed7",
          "load-005.save.000005": "94f2f40639e05c6e4057517a8a605a015d600effe48e1df145ff9c03a611e240",
          "load-006.chkpt.000006": "ce4cc26ddb9970e6a1360a9b5289140bcbc53f38449365a0d650d528c09207cb",
          "load-006.info": "8b761345ea33b8de101c20aa8cc043f28188192a284a734a10ef7750e54389b2",
          "load-006.save.000005": "9f24d200709cf75915227372bd5e3c5f3427067d469f04f7f44433fcc435056a",
          "load-006.save.000006": "b2fc67565eb50e1f3180d4ee2c715d96c519a6899b7879f5d45eb618b0ac0f2d",
          "load-007.chkpt.000007": "52db94bcd86a36155c83976989e1a11c5f013e29e92f166ad270ccef9ffb069c",
          "load-007.info": "ea9cffffb9cd603bfe04323d1b4096d2220c28e096990c865c10138cb6bd2987",
          "load-007.save.000006": "457a556b22393b6d7792392fe4523c58de8ddd23fe924b5d42f2505838460295",
          "load-007.save.000007": "94a55efc3280e158ce903851112f49773e286dc621934997dbd8c7c9c6eb141e",
          "load-008.chkpt.000008": "28920fcb4ad18ce8bd293942572d5c6154fb3fc65b4d3b3dbb0b34bb9b330bd5",
          "load-008.info": "64880c9b61f33ce968c4a0e6ade89754ce7a07c31c16f779adbb1424b04a027c",
          "load-008.save.000007": "14a84c33da41793fcf5a039192a3885609e276c467bd397561c563d12a24f905",
          "load-008.save.000008": "c72002fd7c478ff57451a80f9365e1302638adb9955f3c11bcbc5843e2a1cc0d",
          "load-009.chkpt.000009": "3450a37caab0e07a171c825ce18e84be0e00e7cf3d09687e03d7c9ddc80196dd",
          "load-009.info": "fb4894371f81948efee0877b3b504faf9c5ac1a339ab604d36fc1e228bd2c82d",
          "load-009.save.000008": "62a0e374d765a697a64593ad6744eb6bffc5e04f29cbd238fe98a782f97a344c",
          "load-009.save.000009": "275ca9e78f10ed360f02dda0afd333ef863b98830f50bca6a86595435d257611",
          "load-010.chkpt.000010": "b3e5c912d599b3c39b10d8c08622dabfc24fac163101167858203e16bfa98188",
          "load-010.info": "42f65d5d21c0acb444ac849f965fa691b596cd0cf9a271579e21a01212ce7e8b",
          "load-010.save.000009": "60454316bd675630f62e1ae0d06881becc66e65c8647a4c5adb415f9243b9d5f",
          "load-010.save.000010": "89e989c6a802b16e5e624c1d12f3106a5df9358baeec526636b17a25a31df854",
          "load-011.chkpt.000011": "17eefe1904ad2f1d2fd2cb88bfcfc1fb3ea6c3d7007fc8deb45e8834a1ca6fc1",
          "load-011.info": "23f77ab9dbccea1957bb8316806366566ea0129f77c08047429c9612e2d8b5ac",
          "load-011.save.000010": "6b9d423e0d3cacb4592eb966d44bcc0c93d3038725d3039845ef864a66acea52",
          "load-011.save.000011": "f326bbbb8b38c9175e771a564f01bde1bb1647dc08ed6956d14bf4f3b2705635",
          "load-012.chkpt.000012": "ba2b9483521d00801cc679133eb184343c60e198c908b4439b59c968d1016f9c",
          "load-012.info": "f3cf2d5ee4329f60ce85c4ea1a5a796fc9d7eda1431d6b18a52f7f4b522a138d",
          "load-012.save.000011": "f1308cb73281460c95c45d0accbea85b8784d9c25940a08be461ecf3df6875e7",
          "load-012.save.000012": "6fb3fe56a940a3f2e82fef9f157a5efc58322c8aab6b0e22514d332526028a33",
          "load-013.chkpt.000013": "cc5c8f8cfc88e129df41d8f243ffa87ec549739885126d5ccbb3499bd065d50a",
          "load-013.info": "06bc85c705d7551bc906dc92f9ce59be9cc2864e006e5512a0079aa0ecfe94b7",
          "load-013.save.000012": "6a3a7b9fe0d06c30fab96b8c5c55a6ce539ae5ee9429b1202310df95a1c43620",
          "load-013.save.000013": "cd38256aca164963411c237a8c4def50e682a22984f17a759a49dd1d5fa586e5",
          "load-014.chkpt.000014": "f2df456d2630744b4915fc1b1e219c5f6cd0d239007fb315356424edcaeb53b4",
          "load-014.info": "17e77b3fb696c6fe9dc6ddcb0d0641b846b7bb6970a5866feb746a5e67167e93",
          "load-014.save.000013": "2ada11690c497644306c13de8df9578fed863192d536a65375b1f356a4ff681b",
          "load-014.save.000014": "37609c19e0668443144d234a9911440c3d81a813a7c2afe7fa1914b760562fa9",
          "load-015.chkpt.000015": "327064e5c3885d3ec601302ee3cd8580a14b29f70f0cb4761e1272f0f09385f0",
          "load-015.info": "7bb7d8494f44858939ea54e5a67b53553abba835524368e7afdd38bf619a43a6",
          "load-015.save.000014": "cb4bd5ab760db7b826fd779030d15812880bf65f4ad1f9a7f149fa0736306f78",
          "load-015.save.000015": "4580aeea1134d81a22a6d0a41cb457ae592fa1ecd9517528358b3abb34602870",
          "salencon.chkpt.000016": "edcec165ceb55ca7f87f6675a3034d5ed3c5471dbfac6ed3a8320adf31f44669",
          "salencon.info": "d1426c24cdc32bb8cefe13bed4e2c20f561485beefa37793362d679b3e0a6d9a",
          "salencon.save.000015": "1f86e327951a44befec31eb442b5fea461588e0b0ddf91b670e1593878b26129",
          "salencon.save.000016": "696b4912121409f938cfdc4696f61e20c373024f392c8bfb2162aa2136fe53b2",
          "seed.chkpt.000000": "5387624c088b92fb4aac37a3bdb4db22c7b21b2e412aed3421bf25927630b1bd",
          "seed.chkpt.000001": "59abb1bbc90e964643e040e35b09c172583b3535012a65e3f382913b1d859607",
          "seed.info": "3071230dc02e4f716967b781242dd91c2c1d4760c41d7d38709a94bdb080f1b8",
          "seed.save.000000": "49a3825004fc7a19158d6b09123f15123fa214f3bfdf5e86d80edc8f6fa92082",
          "seed.save.000001": "86fe172f55119b34f0bc69f85da4643a2e174076c63b3366e9b177f35c5eaa28"
        }
      },
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.1,
        "folder": "../mixed-graded-h0.1/h0.1",
        "nodes": 2653,
        "elements": 5106,
        "errors": {
          "radial_stress_rms": 0.009346372321001883,
          "hoop_stress_rms": 0.04878424306997851,
          "out_of_plane_rms": 0.018500951240479523,
          "radial_strain_rms": 0.09800329594111572,
          "hoop_strain_rms": 0.06509481402676313,
          "shear_stress_rms": 0.011496983812505393,
          "displacement_rms_over_wall": 0.00807896145517478,
          "displacement_max_over_wall": 0.069802323152584,
          "plastic_radius_relative": 0.007668072164807138
        },
        "yield_admissibility": {
          "elements": 2219,
          "outside_yield": 92,
          "min_slack_Pa": -194347.11630539858,
          "max_violation_over_P": 0.38869423261079716
        },
        "max_free_force_over_PR": 2.735320332568491e-08,
        "accepted_max_force_over_PR": 6.936496577210597e-14,
        "plastic_radius_m": 1.3850478474929933,
        "reference_plastic_radius_m": 1.395750563538275,
        "reference_wall_displacement_m": -5.3801959740366954e-05,
        "maximum_abs_strain": 0.00020492333548917968,
        "inputs_sha256": {
          "annulus.poly": "042d7c38747edd0f1e303b4e6f48f1d51745402d6ab89ad88cfcdeb5976c8861",
          "load-001.cfg": "6fdd263835e06ba77c4b2faed4370de48b78db7bd4c0ade485734923077e1c8d",
          "load-002.cfg": "5807321ae53c229f7a0cd821b5db2ff72195a7f3a8f5215e382c30cbd1287039",
          "load-003.cfg": "7f5f884f68a75aa615bd281eda044dc82c90af10c13e3d38a8aca779d58777bf",
          "load-004.cfg": "6a3171b6edb41efce98f25a6b1ae5c619442637606266b8a1b627a7c1e538d5c",
          "load-005.cfg": "10a2b11c17f66c03368d7822e684e70ef9ca3057427a699afbf36ea50628d372",
          "load-006.cfg": "a57284bd76543938e19212cbac28e2b19c1c5bb739369dab316c2f1c69576c80",
          "load-007.cfg": "9aadccff3f543237ce623260332486bf45beb257a8aa8dd45b5f49d2c2e0027c",
          "load-008.cfg": "e78bb3cdd881b77245923022ab45e69201768f62b9769a82a4f78cc35d046722",
          "load-009.cfg": "d825b8b986ed185cf23a3dec8b5f6ac32b683e282da6543a14bdcbef54b3be1d",
          "load-010.cfg": "a29b6fe4f64589d1cc4339f8f35111af60d1ef62d4354f8fe8e9625d8fbf893a",
          "load-011.cfg": "1421ca06e4b2c84a5cdaf02c4401eb04031f7a1196f49840727a1c6d6e3e7312",
          "load-012.cfg": "78278591c38417d33ffc188fc085f9a042efa983614c29c418d0cd99128f5a11",
          "load-013.cfg": "41368121b8d67533eeb3b3f09af4abb5e8072f5cc6cc160b58d5ad6eabf35c63",
          "load-014.cfg": "08fb727e7837717f04e7d26b954de0e3fee74b201956959c73598051bc10ddc8",
          "load-015.cfg": "2a3530be45b6bcefba8e2cae2744e8206dc4ad966c0cc5ffd5a0034111d06ed7",
          "load-path.json": "a5ae765cc4a19eb48c0753379221d15125cea1b5a01d97bd71c9d8606c1c8e96",
          "salencon.cfg": "44183cca2f315aebc1f99812455af969139d81aaf7e653c11d19554cfe03fc65",
          "seed.cfg": "e068e3798b3c389758b099d3193f97b551ce5b72919368469ae32f24262f7122"
        },
        "outputs_sha256": {
          "load-001.chkpt.000001": "b41a096c46424898b464aa90fe35cfab5583b390542ca9f3332699aade16c521",
          "load-001.info": "cc0dc2d0e31d4454370329f5d57c7327a9b52c4f5f2ca90125db3ba5e238857c",
          "load-001.save.000000": "b3eea45e919ffbbf13824a52c5e966fa67d7258a50e8a28289fbeabe51c0fa62",
          "load-001.save.000001": "5f796d6afbba886561c002f4c14b37ae7f6c9c7ca9a9389426c59eb76b20e360",
          "load-002.chkpt.000002": "0cb8e81f3e10855bbb7f5b674d6cb922a9ed1e99d93015fd064d8244e68d93de",
          "load-002.info": "3359c65e6918f87aca9c7f6e9eb8086b254fabfc906ae4f9190bb85d1d16ef1e",
          "load-002.save.000001": "9ba45aab6571cac5860d7dff9ab5167f5479238bab1512f3d9bbb1125315d1b1",
          "load-002.save.000002": "52b70d8352be054a32455bcb6b0cf33d88d9e1c4d232c52390d02910a5dd66f8",
          "load-003.chkpt.000003": "06795c876a986c18e0cdeae2c70d7161f67f7a5fe5d1046333527b97f043ac1c",
          "load-003.info": "3b5044ee73963e99c114702da1a4b1b29609fdf91ada029ca5ad671d10710c37",
          "load-003.save.000002": "a9537c3411de07c8cc7ebb9558d82d2bbc368062d20eb4f9797ca0e0904361bb",
          "load-003.save.000003": "7dbe06b507b36817c7596bf088e7a7943333ea52c58f3c1fda4e397be4391fb2",
          "load-004.chkpt.000004": "86ae645fb916a09ce5af4a95afa57d50ae894cb1c50660e68a6d03231a0a3e6a",
          "load-004.info": "c518354e705f5c21a57426f7e5190ac4878da21eda8df09a7871ca9f4daed2c3",
          "load-004.save.000003": "13ddb0f06049a4b096968a0b44e37b29d9ddb6cfffc3aa6cd3ae3f3cea266c07",
          "load-004.save.000004": "e8e54d29a824357b3fbc41774c11dc4ba33e87b1269396108093d132c9dc787b",
          "load-005.chkpt.000005": "e87f71e8cd2c4678f0ea36affe3054a70325e26a06c720e61b928ae49c4618ea",
          "load-005.info": "10e70647d144345b971b4efe900266982598ec2e2417f8c54e9eaf46ac56110b",
          "load-005.save.000004": "9fb2b6563f4d9177fd97e62e34ef22243cb7c8e17a029462d752fc63c56f12d1",
          "load-005.save.000005": "445c667d1e51ae6b43d5a9c4e372a72d9a8b97f1e66758561d43123e661211e4",
          "load-006.chkpt.000006": "96f7ff716da4980f1fc0815d19514ff6ad7aace47afc98bc7824a688f60e8519",
          "load-006.info": "6192c4e43a1cbbcfa649b13a8587082c4d37ec1a4c137945fb53d4af03824da9",
          "load-006.save.000005": "7dbec559a1e233b24dd7465576142f1b67339fbab64d7a3f467e965c0316281b",
          "load-006.save.000006": "96b6d39eba832af22eccb0a712529b5a732c717f551b6d75b86577e463b0054f",
          "load-007.chkpt.000007": "d26bc3343dfe58b7feeea791e0562faff455b0440cfbcea6fab6294c1e500397",
          "load-007.info": "0ee229daf46fa473b574f1a604868c5a0ddaf907bcdffdeb0e2415aad41b87c5",
          "load-007.save.000006": "24a69ccde97c97744cd9212c71d754d11ab1e42f12bb43a18f1510fa4f8c3cf5",
          "load-007.save.000007": "2a3c598f3b0ed78063f7e5de2c81fa744b4726e83817cae73f215f1748739eea",
          "load-008.chkpt.000008": "f04d3c60d82cd842079efd912e354c98340e97a2f61419ac4859c17f777a5c1c",
          "load-008.info": "30b6045bcf671959f41829886d535184d0eebda91934319aee0d8dbf7a8a0374",
          "load-008.save.000007": "23db57356c63516572cbc2f2d006fa7dea47fa88180a3da5691c692bd3cec6f5",
          "load-008.save.000008": "28e3e0546f9a31f51b87cc146827769b3fae19056e4389ce911b2e970c2c5d23",
          "load-009.chkpt.000009": "721d3eb17b529ad0a88c7a905b7c143f5789ac6846963f9117fa22c3fa266f99",
          "load-009.info": "8682fbb2ecabcd1148bc662338ff9c41cd56e7c7ec335686b1574ec3e998321b",
          "load-009.save.000008": "63a2558615a2d63633cb8507b8f73361b198c89791e7a49dff8fcb9afbc05e5c",
          "load-009.save.000009": "18551b6ea9ab246dc4565cde160fb6f6ad71aa3a4db03ee5bd8d5b06096fe628",
          "load-010.chkpt.000010": "ee02dc6049ef0a26907c7040a4670bc518cc127939e7137ba07c2f3c18da18ae",
          "load-010.info": "a3741e7b1aceea09b829bb30ee0148e6ada6f8e60ed65d3ee0d54386dff5a308",
          "load-010.save.000009": "f970fb72edea2c496c770b4a5ea6bdafab31335d73e9bccf54b68e596068f298",
          "load-010.save.000010": "76caa714586c2b4b663028c4f6d2779fc6d4d7ae4490c9b6c84569a3deca2863",
          "load-011.chkpt.000011": "efc72f54ba9e7ebfe0e2219985322e5bd6b54511700eb3baa4b47629153391a5",
          "load-011.info": "b840f86f9d970c6e875830185c3e7c7b0624571aac712dc28c78102b907995e6",
          "load-011.save.000010": "7f2daeaa4111ef268b41d7bf646d4246fa26ed834d758fe3f4b731d18283fff0",
          "load-011.save.000011": "287a89bb78f8e70c39daaaf154fc00e63df4cb48f18fb30bbf1df4dc632b12e3",
          "load-012.chkpt.000012": "42e0b3ce27a6d37d413656b178b614a2e22fbdd0d59dfb7b50718d28ef2db3f2",
          "load-012.info": "643a911fff3bc19df207cec8eb31403e9e782dbaa2b66c4d701b622daac64120",
          "load-012.save.000011": "b9f3d27408c386ce3fc36e9273f2d7f35bc209b92e4cb469938b2cf24bfed98c",
          "load-012.save.000012": "4b7e8dfadd68f84d465aa6273328705cd5870424fc4eb2b6e6380ebb4ad1bcf8",
          "load-013.chkpt.000013": "88ea6ad5ef532854b7cb1432e3c44187f850216f000ffda165338c396dc29e90",
          "load-013.info": "a3d3733f4dc524258ea11931893a7e72538a1e1c2904571ed912f2edfd683281",
          "load-013.save.000012": "9b01cf9fdaaaf24384ff48918d017adbb4de40c4f58d98db002f1393a1cdb933",
          "load-013.save.000013": "93c4e369fc34efbef59c5aa9e869fadc3d1b5c05cf8c43cc02e4f8a2e5e716a9",
          "load-014.chkpt.000014": "852e3b3b758c1138159baa9a8b365c7f26198dc22fc9b95aae3844291928e691",
          "load-014.info": "c29086885f9ad6607a048931050472dace093067f5bf20d1b6267ce40f497fe7",
          "load-014.save.000013": "3fe215f2ca12bd456dd44b69917152173011698bd81f8fb013d438eedaf6dabd",
          "load-014.save.000014": "399146d320204bf5fcd599eb307976c34068f8e70225b6f1d762500b86bdfa4d",
          "load-015.chkpt.000015": "2a9d7cdd33ca128cf4693000b4b7ac54230eaf13f0cd4598431d8b7df0cdde1f",
          "load-015.info": "c2f7b83b853f8542963a87c5fcff4ef2e37acab2344c5f87b19ab16228a4209c",
          "load-015.save.000014": "f8f1423e2792f8ef7563981429196a2718a484b5c69590ada83595e1cd32679e",
          "load-015.save.000015": "e189f590672870761e9ecc98c1cc52d5484d809010bacdc1afe9c5d753c384ea",
          "salencon.chkpt.000016": "140829b8a4a0a3bc57c422abf7c05df6416c24ed1c1d9edc593d067acef06ec7",
          "salencon.info": "ca624c456cde2a012fe8d9f36d127735c16075e75675e2e618628a28ff5d3228",
          "salencon.save.000015": "65126f3e2b43be0793c9fb55a8c1c906e93903e63a716fd72183dfb2edbf128f",
          "salencon.save.000016": "acb7e08f29b2f0beb37120b8cc1778b09a73172731a4049f0dc5e51b435459d8",
          "seed.chkpt.000000": "43a71a0f8b47daa9de4dccd0ea9c8e66b762ddd23c415f7c43bffad6e5e63162",
          "seed.chkpt.000001": "051e07b1dbbe7079d66d8cdb0d35652ba565e148813e5a4a4c473d93bbad48a5",
          "seed.info": "a8f6729f99b13d6b4ba031d3e431c700f5f44553808c0c247c21c8cba7e71eef",
          "seed.save.000000": "09feabd88642eb984ee5516e32f66bdbc9053b8505b2f884481d44ed62761cdd",
          "seed.save.000001": "98135a3a967ef3782ce0bf9c9f913b8fcba53bfcbeab0f663a66fbf88d75fe96"
        }
      },
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.05,
        "folder": "../mixed-graded-h0.05/h0.05",
        "nodes": 10151,
        "elements": 19898,
        "errors": {
          "radial_stress_rms": 0.003604685356750517,
          "hoop_stress_rms": 0.015669343621469076,
          "out_of_plane_rms": 0.006134018372404212,
          "radial_strain_rms": 0.0387854815364042,
          "hoop_strain_rms": 0.02066916230087953,
          "shear_stress_rms": 0.0044482812665655146,
          "displacement_rms_over_wall": 0.0021299614919050133,
          "displacement_max_over_wall": 0.02372724592254514,
          "plastic_radius_relative": 0.0033599085020705743
        },
        "yield_admissibility": {
          "elements": 8496,
          "outside_yield": 374,
          "min_slack_Pa": -95572.3242016185,
          "max_violation_over_P": 0.191144648403237
        },
        "max_free_force_over_PR": 6.4706008061002434e-09,
        "accepted_max_force_over_PR": 1.339049083878289e-13,
        "plastic_radius_m": 1.3910609693530729,
        "reference_plastic_radius_m": 1.395750563538275,
        "reference_wall_displacement_m": -5.3801959740366954e-05,
        "maximum_abs_strain": 0.00019107600048852042,
        "inputs_sha256": {
          "annulus.poly": "12db757495105e1cf875a7d78dfe80448dc8eedb735f859980d03fb3e3fc7d90",
          "load-001.cfg": "b5eec5caabc637908eb4d8a9983dee50adb90265502ba351221491228ddeffac",
          "load-002.cfg": "c2eb68eb655f00190dad79f9d85c845345548a5b43764f5d4c43c73905dcc24d",
          "load-003.cfg": "d796197326f9a6c2c246ec9f7f8cc4323824130afeabff9b0b0c2b79e93d951e",
          "load-004.cfg": "e7c1d647eec806e0378d7ddc6d802ad4608f9bd76ffcf08317680e90980098e6",
          "load-005.cfg": "5fe2de9e08719524ef557e7318e8a2f148c1552ebe00fbec555bfc5791f74615",
          "load-006.cfg": "132bd2e4760c63cc882024e58a555fc912835ee01f49a12ccf7c936b4ed330fa",
          "load-007.cfg": "de50b83c57980ae670b80cb61ae1e614fb8010a6c2ab4b6cb6ae4d663c20525d",
          "load-008.cfg": "9f8f748bfc5868469c9de5a66b9f162a78e50076469eec74be2c9ecddb1a9b3e",
          "load-009.cfg": "16bbbd5bc6e085e4b9c7c5dfed13f12bb2893cc57a89fc32cee479a550433bb6",
          "load-010.cfg": "3a5200c3b00d8dc73a4b229c3722e5cf31933f080cd074d0927a22f8c40c2852",
          "load-011.cfg": "e6a6f84ef449e9a35c806ca5be8e18bde5401f2d473f5cf6d6667abe8edfdc21",
          "load-012.cfg": "5cc0e016cf81eeed887b4c63270b0c1d3f681d17009a93e373f0c79661087019",
          "load-013.cfg": "91117401e3109d691f6e6c88db2384fc6c3dfdbad2583b5fcaf148f70d7e139c",
          "load-014.cfg": "45a683f8721dd38ade8515bb6e2f013d5ab187d53358ce74711adf4d280cbd28",
          "load-015.cfg": "303cd41cd35a4f6a0711df304d8adb521a34d2fbd22f8000f9646b0869947b14",
          "load-path.json": "a5ae765cc4a19eb48c0753379221d15125cea1b5a01d97bd71c9d8606c1c8e96",
          "salencon.cfg": "b659bf6b437d6990cceaf2bf47fe5afd57d67a97d5af258706650c071a460583",
          "seed.cfg": "33d196cbcf11b3eddd98b7b22b331ea2796ba429b9d6233d23d74cb3fb8d16bf"
        },
        "outputs_sha256": {
          "load-001.chkpt.000001": "d0290b72cad93ee9c6cab514d32707803805264d92ec353ced44f6ad5e232f66",
          "load-001.info": "9a52b1c66b7124da8037301effccebe3ed031b099cd31c9b9644fca97cdafa6c",
          "load-001.save.000000": "8ad7801da865e0067b055f9da15baf420ab46c0cbbb81e5620a3e0212eb7d750",
          "load-001.save.000001": "f9a29727c26b3a521b223a32d0501e8a45df5a4637def4a64114a92a5feb57ce",
          "load-002.chkpt.000002": "d03faa61a74452dc3589555e0c234685d63cd8857830f6a66262db1c86e34206",
          "load-002.info": "b594d7d481e5bca979bb123a494e29eb7778b5c0e870cb3867b9be58ca9c5772",
          "load-002.save.000001": "25994faf0359158dca7d2c1b55af2c3667f1b9978f6a0939135e12f2544e1242",
          "load-002.save.000002": "4a0b0e9dd1b525198291aeebb49e7897045ecdae6f8e392eefca89f28f83eaa8",
          "load-003.chkpt.000003": "674b326a9b09e39eb9415f80a00c4fd89339ec2679718279573740f7137e990c",
          "load-003.info": "376174d4e925517d3d10f1723f0fe8322e2e51534f78d359915fb372e2d1c594",
          "load-003.save.000002": "d44b6a996aed029e488d47380877c46693b19e36b1321ee9d13386de0bb4154c",
          "load-003.save.000003": "7f8d83d8076850fc6bec2633dd27fe772a66820e6d7db41fd6ae9bd37970cce4",
          "load-004.chkpt.000004": "45af47c39dfdf14526229504cae1b67f1d11a8bdeef0c70ecec663ae2e92c2a5",
          "load-004.info": "b2eb807df830eb493a69f52017de973b3d9efd98fda745fe4f90854231feb11d",
          "load-004.save.000003": "34838858c1a9930ced33a240430c96d0e86453f20f6739389cefb92d436f06a3",
          "load-004.save.000004": "bc3341ace71ce74bfb2e10430616007237b44e34966fb0b2f2ef774dc3d6f129",
          "load-005.chkpt.000005": "c0825ddda01275c9071be2b1a59500387552bb6f3cbf734dc5270107f0e6671d",
          "load-005.info": "4a11a0a57f9e958e5ecfae278ca821066daa08cdf9b9e55ecfb1b0e10c30aee0",
          "load-005.save.000004": "99d296b514a30584dcdc6ec52fead2d5e56cd753f7d6094c73445d167c45c251",
          "load-005.save.000005": "b47d617d44fde243ad2bde53fadb0c05289e7ec06dd83e2e137995f0b5cdf4b6",
          "load-006.chkpt.000006": "2da2e39e77c9acc793bdbea76168e799b62ffb53f280d717984f2a17228b7c9e",
          "load-006.info": "67ff420d224afa092847360f07f87b1fccfe80014a452ab728a6680391ece556",
          "load-006.save.000005": "f4386df0d68f920acafbc78f932fe30b62ef476ba59dfce0b71d3f513dcde1e1",
          "load-006.save.000006": "9fb92da59292c477552f7a91b8430bc8361e16382e317421f34f5f9ce47a3b78",
          "load-007.chkpt.000007": "e1a692a2c157380b4ca19140515b97ccd4b92447ef0b6330a61c6de1a04d68fb",
          "load-007.info": "e14f3e96a73a2a1d20e8a675c7cf3467b879df325f871ad11c9b1df6bdc7fd7e",
          "load-007.save.000006": "4b02df1316d64e81faa19bfd315f279dd1964f34ab200e2ee3f276d32684f4e7",
          "load-007.save.000007": "c5ffa6e49a4143fd9e7140b81994411632a177f43d854fef18b24b437d635611",
          "load-008.chkpt.000008": "9a61c95e39c1f8ca5946e5b36f55c705282536e241b75bf837c490a007206386",
          "load-008.info": "d817bc6dce66c3459b4cc7bacd18b4c2a380dde7209f7545dc82aad5ced33b14",
          "load-008.save.000007": "918a991866229424e455f5f83f2b4e581d5d8f1f464e3f91c80fffa738249326",
          "load-008.save.000008": "7985fb9d63ff3d7f6ce10680508137ab60cc6e6beff8629400256354bf5f3305",
          "load-009.chkpt.000009": "d2df5e9f8ccda70b103c99cdfaf0eefa2ba6b11b6ea23acd2f5c23a2857d8985",
          "load-009.info": "4e593ea6a5d91f093bd9df23f1753235eccaf15f5764dc4b9a555d3df41631ef",
          "load-009.save.000008": "0c8b06d15e7709e791bed16aa9f84ab9bed7a8d89b5db404fd5a54a531782e44",
          "load-009.save.000009": "7ea8650d6ae873dab751589aff70aff6178abe37a241eec4e7fdd603409ef05c",
          "load-010.chkpt.000010": "bb5650b45f51d7642469dcf8d1ba57c4df6a6d7eb78afd319c4a1e908f500b05",
          "load-010.info": "339861a4364e3102dd4a4c78e335705774fc102016725648f69df8cc561e0fb5",
          "load-010.save.000009": "5e00ed151c10e4a165a42111c7dc4771427f4e713f0b41c1f1ddfb8064646d01",
          "load-010.save.000010": "abddbb185eeff50bb9dcf914ed5525aac5bc90e61e57fc95f0360adf76b774ce",
          "load-011.chkpt.000011": "f29012ff68be56db6564900e4a2617a0e34dfadfcccdd55208430aec656f12ce",
          "load-011.info": "093ada3e3da59277bfd8194bb1d281f9b37600dc7bfe763f92c3494112f09e4d",
          "load-011.save.000010": "db5f15ff6670905ae84b2ab5dde992ae236774d11489d3c4e633477de3f780e5",
          "load-011.save.000011": "8d3a19d9529fa4d2fa5555939906e42e50f411fec897b6be6e3c85a197d5a32a",
          "load-012.chkpt.000012": "f0719324fc32f09447999347456d21916d844a85a4626b730e55413d2f881306",
          "load-012.info": "588713e58cb8dae5eb63b16f971423ce518fb5918bd0bd60e8189c0c1b954573",
          "load-012.save.000011": "180dc642a3d4ea4026f37ce8e0834e9a2d15ebd9f9876142ce464fede778dae2",
          "load-012.save.000012": "c86e06db8a059462d2ee4efbfd92dd4bc877d81027f6497f3ea2013a8f7cee22",
          "load-013.chkpt.000013": "753844fa726115ab64f41505e275c2e808f881dfae2d24db7427f9606d96bddd",
          "load-013.info": "4dfa45ce62f2639061389187863fdef150b34b2c5cf4cd792f44be1974065e46",
          "load-013.save.000012": "5ac76a2bf49a231710446edfb9182ad3959f2e065660e90dfda5f8fe9edf5ea2",
          "load-013.save.000013": "6c041464238bd03308e7f69d37eb07fcc84be136733796b98a1c708172ffced8",
          "load-014.chkpt.000014": "07831fce3d3271b71ffa766636f699ddcefb758bf258ec16b1287c7a24f82b6c",
          "load-014.info": "6f2acc5481606e2ba076875195add145597fe138f4065cf69615a14a0edefaaa",
          "load-014.save.000013": "4c37bae908b61850b8ecadc4af4d291740f228351424a6b68442d69251853f09",
          "load-014.save.000014": "e2444356b4c9383f7af878babb5ec00bbf161644a274bcce29e74d1d87efc8dc",
          "load-015.chkpt.000015": "1d549baa062de6f0d1b03c53b39c1bce9c23f6d1298651321a32f0b81ff58773",
          "load-015.info": "b3b89a69943e0f7d802350c7f4cbc92e8e6ffe7f52d04c5bb0c18ff42b3111b8",
          "load-015.save.000014": "50b0ccc2debd1dc5e7184d30d767a1c478c56b98a3062b7fdf5e9436a13c5c28",
          "load-015.save.000015": "a71acbe2987efeeb11de6f96a56377f68302535aaab5a308d1148bc67d39fc65",
          "salencon.chkpt.000016": "e9996473a8f84cdff0e68f31b01bcd6b9306dc1e4495978636d5098ac70e7140",
          "salencon.info": "68e89933dcd9015d5f028db41ab27fba24384e4bb6c704da0133648d94b21b3a",
          "salencon.save.000015": "e42b3a28040ac314e545e73081565ae1f6d653704eb952c5dae52ccb2234e831",
          "salencon.save.000016": "c623805b712b34a7be9d5949560072a207fe8b69233220cc7c437f5baae9f3dc",
          "seed.chkpt.000000": "de3f7968b16ba31bfd897eb4ea93555e083a4045dfb5834ad91a9d7d03bd3ec1",
          "seed.chkpt.000001": "82d17fa968e402f409b9e0e07139c67b1c1278d0e9b32e872a33384c29cd2006",
          "seed.info": "aea0d3d626fcdf3760b5ccaf2c3bd7256699ec51c36a7002f052343c061dd760",
          "seed.save.000000": "e0c3b5470af08805ae3ee3a9082ad93b6987d31d79101e2d0cf5d477b8ecc8d7",
          "seed.save.000001": "d118b864a714ee12d70dd96df6f68a1d59ff0ba2d2a9228fb17d195723ca6694"
        }
      }
    ],
    "passed": false,
    "scope": "Dry isotropic unloading, perfect Mohr-Coulomb, plane strain; no fluid injection.",
    "execution_completed": true,
    "force_qualified": true,
    "accuracy_qualified": false,
    "yield_check_applied": false,
    "yield_check_scope": "Diagnostic of saved mixed stress; local return tested separately.",
    "assessment_source_sha256": {
      "tests/functional/hydromechanics/check_salencon.py": "e52f41e4c6a4bb13b13dd3aca922940207fa91273201337a5c321b45472b6bc2",
      "tests/functional/hydromechanics/check_kirsch.py": "33e439ffe61786a855a66c1f498c374d30bbb7722ea4dfeed2e279db02183869",
      "benchmarks/hydromechanics/salencon_reference.py": "1d7dde83664a65b982bd11affd87d789342f12c485601707b3835cd797753d97",
      "Dynearthsol.py": "b6049b051ded93e5c3f21b66e14511c48b3acb818769d2ecff01a698bbf2b45e",
      "tests/functional/pt_initial_checkpoint.py": "713d0ca9399a2d16d6d1a7212b9972a297d0b551b19c135e44faced4b712820e"
    },
    "solver_source_manifest": "benchmarks/hydromechanics/results/runs/shear-cap-20261108/qualification.json"
  }
}
