{
  "problem": "Injected water carries its temperature. DES adds the injected enthalpy relative to the local temperature, which with fluid mass conservation makes its advective heat equation conserve energy. Two checks: radial hot-water injection against Avdonin’s solution, and a sealed doublet against an independent heat ledger.",
  "result": "Avdonin on the 0.1 m mesh: largest nodal error 1.50% of $T_{in}-T_0$ at 5.8 d (rms 0.28%). Doublet: stored heat follows the ledger within 0.019% after the first step, through breakthrough (producer at 78% of $T_{in}-T_0$).",
  "scope": "2D. Avdonin errors fall at first order with the mesh (0.4 m: 5.80%, 0.2 m: 2.84%, 0.1 m: 1.50%), as expected of the first-order (limited) advection scheme; time steps 200: 2.89%, 1000: 2.89% on the 0.2 m mesh. Thermal advection uses the Darcy flux at the start of each step, so a source switched on from rest loses part of its first step of heat when that step needs several thermal substeps: 0.75 of one step's injected heat on the 0.2 m doublet, 0.92 of one step's injected heat on the 0.1 m doublet; its share of the total falls as $1/t$. 3D check, a slab one element thick: largest error 5.75% (0.4 m), stored heat within 6e-06. (a) Avdonin profiles; (b) doublet ledger; (c) errors.",
  "meaning": "This checks the injected-enthalpy term with open outflow (Avdonin) and with outflow at a changing temperature (doublet), measured against energy conservation rather than inferred from the equation.",
  "metric": 0.015034572672104786,
  "metric_label": "temperature error",
  "spacing_m": 0.1,
  "evidence": {
    "executable_sha256": "389e460d3fa6531ea6fa6d95fb7f7ab251c45cf61ba430fe510c44b13892910a",
    "reproduction_revision": "3774df00ba1708a4f70a836d2073f845653aac64",
    "avdonin": [
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.4,
        "nodes": 441,
        "frames": [
          {
            "time": 125000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.11664814354111058,
            "temperature_rms": 0.013015550514560586,
            "stored_heat": 130624206.2223744,
            "injected_heat": 130625000.0,
            "heat_error": 6.076766511764475e-06,
            "far_side": 0.0
          },
          {
            "time": 250000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.08541439249054406,
            "temperature_rms": 0.011988546476507466,
            "stored_heat": 261249206.2223672,
            "injected_heat": 261250000.0,
            "heat_error": 3.0383832834157687e-06,
            "far_side": 0.0
          },
          {
            "time": 375000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.07153648546584578,
            "temperature_rms": 0.011717040273585475,
            "stored_heat": 391874206.22232026,
            "injected_heat": 391875000.0,
            "heat_error": 2.0255889754405842e-06,
            "far_side": 3.8249936551437713e-10
          },
          {
            "time": 500000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.057992153764271276,
            "temperature_rms": 0.011500277418197513,
            "stored_heat": 522499206.2156011,
            "injected_heat": 522500000.0,
            "heat_error": 1.5192045912382213e-06,
            "far_side": 3.960479943998507e-08
          }
        ],
        "input_sha256": "0732352b305d0171f5033adb7c7207f3b71369c4c46037d880bc3c3a2e9e18ea",
        "temperature_error": 0.11664814354111058,
        "heat_error": 6.076766511764475e-06
      },
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.2,
        "nodes": 1681,
        "frames": [
          {
            "time": 125000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.05521953226550295,
            "temperature_rms": 0.005583525231119307,
            "stored_heat": 130624206.99607041,
            "injected_heat": 130625000.0,
            "heat_error": 6.070843480032728e-06,
            "far_side": 0.0
          },
          {
            "time": 250000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.03963937987376426,
            "temperature_rms": 0.005485286133787548,
            "stored_heat": 261249206.99606487,
            "injected_heat": 261250000.0,
            "heat_error": 3.035421761277135e-06,
            "far_side": 0.0
          },
          {
            "time": 375000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.032852810366840686,
            "temperature_rms": 0.0054634854227204035,
            "stored_heat": 391874206.9960577,
            "injected_heat": 391875000.0,
            "heat_error": 2.02361452583677e-06,
            "far_side": 0.0
          },
          {
            "time": 500000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.02842908367925247,
            "temperature_rms": 0.00545867295975437,
            "stored_heat": 522499206.9960473,
            "injected_heat": 522500000.0,
            "heat_error": 1.5177109142783252e-06,
            "far_side": 3.7914560380158946e-11
          }
        ],
        "input_sha256": "fcadd89d71b801f634675b7b19247f5871ec63cb9e7f92ebc1b164b05ceb094b",
        "temperature_error": 0.05521953226550295,
        "heat_error": 6.070843480032728e-06
      },
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.1,
        "nodes": 6561,
        "frames": [
          {
            "time": 125000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.029912465668002142,
            "temperature_rms": 0.0028140031700272885,
            "stored_heat": 130061181.54642497,
            "injected_heat": 130625000.0,
            "heat_error": 0.0043163135201915726,
            "far_side": 0.0
          },
          {
            "time": 250000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.021230363219702893,
            "temperature_rms": 0.002793654019015982,
            "stored_heat": 260686181.54641026,
            "injected_heat": 261250000.0,
            "heat_error": 0.0021581567601520746,
            "far_side": 0.0
          },
          {
            "time": 375000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.017329579848766343,
            "temperature_rms": 0.002791409153320371,
            "stored_heat": 391311181.5463915,
            "injected_heat": 391875000.0,
            "heat_error": 0.001438771173482678,
            "far_side": 0.0
          },
          {
            "time": 500000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.015034572672104786,
            "temperature_rms": 0.002790818920592553,
            "stored_heat": 521936181.5463722,
            "injected_heat": 522500000.0,
            "heat_error": 0.001079078380148979,
            "far_side": 0.0
          }
        ],
        "input_sha256": "701c955fcaaf65c37c49d56e7f3ff540a88faaa2ff975ac63278fb374b634318",
        "temperature_error": 0.029912465668002142,
        "heat_error": 0.0043163135201915726
      }
    ],
    "steps": [
      [
        {
          "spacing_m": 0.2,
          "nodes": 1681,
          "frames": [
            {
              "time": 125000.0,
              "temperature_error": 0.057621639812346075,
              "temperature_rms": 0.005660777823609592,
              "stored_heat": 129721252.21940094,
              "injected_heat": 130625000.0,
              "heat_error": 0.006918643296452087,
              "far_side": 0.0
            },
            {
              "time": 250000.0,
              "temperature_error": 0.04053835415685967,
              "temperature_rms": 0.005513174025612884,
              "stored_heat": 260346252.21939394,
              "injected_heat": 261250000.0,
              "heat_error": 0.003459321648252911,
              "far_side": 0.0
            },
            {
              "time": 375000.0,
              "temperature_error": 0.033469694220568724,
              "temperature_rms": 0.005474989242581453,
              "stored_heat": 390971252.219386,
              "injected_heat": 391875000.0,
              "heat_error": 0.0023062144321889244,
              "far_side": 0.0
            },
            {
              "time": 500000.0,
              "temperature_error": 0.02889675265241749,
              "temperature_rms": 0.005462468741568552,
              "stored_heat": 521596252.21937525,
              "injected_heat": 522500000.0,
              "heat_error": 0.0017296608241621492,
              "far_side": 3.126388037344441e-11
            }
          ],
          "input_sha256": "df8ecb4ba81262b540d40f7f8c54c477fc80932e7efb6f9553ae07812d07888a",
          "temperature_error": 0.057621639812346075,
          "heat_error": 0.006918643296452087
        }
      ],
      [
        {
          "spacing_m": 0.2,
          "nodes": 1681,
          "frames": [
            {
              "time": 125000.0,
              "temperature_error": 0.057111438275339876,
              "temperature_rms": 0.005788334649413011,
              "stored_heat": 130624145.84867942,
              "injected_heat": 130625000.0,
              "heat_error": 6.538957478152696e-06,
              "far_side": 0.0
            },
            {
              "time": 250000.0,
              "temperature_error": 0.0405715238006303,
              "temperature_rms": 0.005634215950559299,
              "stored_heat": 261249145.84867138,
              "injected_heat": 261250000.0,
              "heat_error": 3.269478769829526e-06,
              "far_side": 0.0
            },
            {
              "time": 375000.0,
              "temperature_error": 0.03348887183220995,
              "temperature_rms": 0.005585615004902087,
              "stored_heat": 391874145.84866613,
              "injected_heat": 391875000.0,
              "heat_error": 2.1796525265793676e-06,
              "far_side": 0.0
            },
            {
              "time": 500000.0,
              "temperature_error": 0.02891106133237372,
              "temperature_rms": 0.0055645033021713315,
              "stored_heat": 522499145.84865814,
              "injected_heat": 522500000.0,
              "heat_error": 1.634739410283359e-06,
              "far_side": 5.064748620497994e-11
            }
          ],
          "input_sha256": "768a273f87294191f451b6c7e09d4d053502be16d71ee5cd328ab66216e58066",
          "temperature_error": 0.057111438275339876,
          "heat_error": 6.538957478152696e-06
        }
      ]
    ],
    "doublet": [
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.2,
        "input_sha256": "b6507dfc870a362e501566a316cc775e14a747d3a470918badb1eed78a2e65f5",
        "nodes": 1681,
        "frames": 401,
        "breakthrough": 38.62566381340844,
        "producer_rise": 0.7725132762681688,
        "start_deficit_steps": 0.7492357964158248,
        "ledger_error": 0.00023683025001148669,
        "final_ledger_error": 0.00010587285421993554,
        "total_error": 0.0017672166368196266,
        "stored_gain": 6186107432.0355,
        "injected": 83516400000.0,
        "extracted": 77308131671.33878
      },
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.1,
        "input_sha256": "478754d2bb82025649e546833340b39290aad014f7ac6a562165df21494e0db3",
        "nodes": 6561,
        "frames": 401,
        "breakthrough": 38.79551300893763,
        "producer_rise": 0.7759102601787526,
        "start_deficit_steps": 0.9241157436184678,
        "ledger_error": 0.0001911906260318543,
        "final_ledger_error": 2.7357556465139798e-05,
        "total_error": 0.0022829318025810296,
        "stored_gain": 6126769552.967941,
        "injected": 83516400000.0,
        "extracted": 77361002482.22769
      }
    ],
    "sanity_3d": [
      {
        "spacing_m": 0.4,
        "nodes": 882,
        "frames": [
          {
            "time": 125000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.12407260179518857,
            "temperature_rms": 0.013526398774631137,
            "stored_heat": 52249682.53776864,
            "injected_heat": 52250000.00000001,
            "heat_error": 6.075832179264218e-06,
            "far_side": 0.0
          },
          {
            "time": 250000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.09341533833595123,
            "temperature_rms": 0.012311179592880056,
            "stored_heat": 104499682.53776464,
            "injected_heat": 104500000.00000001,
            "heat_error": 3.0379161279903144e-06,
            "far_side": 2.8421709430404007e-13
          },
          {
            "time": 375000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.069526503626264,
            "temperature_rms": 0.011552152030900821,
            "stored_heat": 156749682.53774175,
            "injected_heat": 156750000.00000003,
            "heat_error": 2.0252775647655596e-06,
            "far_side": 4.989146873413119e-10
          },
          {
            "time": 500000.0,
            "temperature_error": 0.05752191514649894,
            "temperature_rms": 0.011083625385863017,
            "stored_heat": 208999682.5348061,
            "injected_heat": 209000000.00000003,
            "heat_error": 1.5189722197828104e-06,
            "far_side": 4.7782521050976356e-08
          }
        ],
        "input_sha256": "e7510c667ba4de133714f095bc62431fd7df7aecbd5b6e7eecbb99c384e80793",
        "temperature_error": 0.12407260179518857,
        "heat_error": 6.075832179264218e-06
      }
    ]
  }
}
