Skip to main content
Version: Latest

Onset of hydrothermal convection: Horton–Rogers–Lapwood

Water in a porous box heated from below becomes lighter at the base. Above a critical Rayleigh number buoyancy overturns it into a convection cell; below it, a disturbance decays.

Fitted onset: against , 0.14% apart; largest growth-rate error: over 5 Rayleigh numbers. The unseeded box stays at rest to round-off: .

At a glance
Dimension2D
Buildmake ndims=2 from the poromechanics source (not yet merged; DynEarthSol #134)
Inputsconvection.zip
Reproduce withDynEarthSol 3774df0

Problem setup​

Setup

Heating and water boundaries. A square porous box is heated from below: at the base and at the top. All four sides are sealed, ; the sides are insulated, .

Initial state. Steady conduction with the hydrostatic pressure of the temperature-dependent water density, plus a 1 mK Gaussian seed centred at m, mid-depth.

What is compared. The amplitude of the temperature mode . Its growth or decay rate is fitted over the second half of each run and compared with linear stability theory. A seed-free run must stay at rest.

Input and how to run​

Every file this example needs is in convection.zip. Run from that folder:

# Runs the seeded 2D box at Ra = 2 Ra_c for 400 steps of 1000 s and writes box.save.* and box.chkpt.* every 10 steps, with box.info listing the frames.
dynearthsol2d input.cfg

Settings that define this example​

SettingValueWhat it does here
control.has_fluid_thermal_advectiontrueturns on heat transport by the Darcy flux
mat.fluid_alpha[0.001]water thermal expansion α_f = 1e-3 /K; with the default gravity it makes warm water buoyant
mat.hydraulic_perm[7.895683520871486e-10]permeability κ, chosen to give Ra = 2 Ra_c in this input; the study varies it from 0.5 to 2 Ra_c
bc.tbc_z011: fixed temperature at the base
bc.tbc_val_z0283.0base temperature T_0 + ΔT = 283 K
bc.tbc_val_z1273.0top temperature T_0 = 273 K; the sides keep the default insulated condition
ic.temperature_option55: linear conduction profile between the top and base, plus a Gaussian seed
ic.temp_anomaly_amplitude0.001seed amplitude 1 mK, small enough for linear growth
ic.temp_anomaly_xcenter0.25seed centred at x = 0.25 m, off the box centre, so it projects on the first mode
ic.temp_anomaly_zcenter-0.5seed at mid-depth
mat.fluid_bulk_modulus[1e3]a compressible pore fluid; pressure still diffuses about 1000 times faster than heat
control.has_poroelastic_pressure_feedbackfalseoff: a rigid matrix, as the reference assumes
mat.therm_cond[1.0]λ = 1 W/(m K); with C = 1 MJ/(m³ K) the conductive time CH²/λ is 1e6 s
control.fixed_dt1000.01000 s; 400 steps cover 0.4 conductive times

input.cfg holds all 59 settings that differ from DES’s defaults; dynearthsol2d -h lists every option with its default.

Output​

See Running the examples for output files, the Python reader and ParaView conversion.

FieldWhat to look at
temperaturenodal temperature; its departure from the conductive profile, projected on cos(πx/W) sin(πz/H), is the mode amplitude in panel (b), and is mapped in panel (c)

Result: DES and the analytical solution​

Result

(a) Fitted growth rate of the first convective mode against Ra/Ra_c: line, linear stability theory; symbols, DES. (b) Mode amplitude against time for each Rayleigh number: symbols, DES; dashed lines, the theoretical rate over the second half of each run. (c) Temperature departure from conduction at the end of the most supercritical run, showing the single convection cell.

This checks Boussinesq buoyancy in Darcy flow together with heat advection, and that the conductive state stays at rest. It does not test finite-amplitude convection (see the Nusselt-number page) or 3D cells; the fastest run reaches a temperature departure of 10.7% of , so its late growth is only approximately linear.

To reproduce the whole study behind this figure, from the DES source folder:

python3 tests/functional/hydromechanics/check_convection.py dynearthsol2d OUT/h0.05 --spacing 0.05 --ratios 0.5 0.9 1.1 1.5 2
python3 tests/functional/hydromechanics/check_convection.py dynearthsol2d OUT/h0.025 --spacing 0.025 --ratios 0.5 0.9 1.1 1.5 2

The study’s full numbers: record.json.

Analytical reference​

Here is height above the base, and is the temperature at which the water density is . is intrinsic permeability, viscosity, the thermal expansivity of water, its specific heat, the bulk conductivity and the bulk heat capacity. The runs use m, K, and , so the conductive time is s; sets .

Derivation​

Conduction with no flow is the base state, , with the hydrostatic pressure of . Perturb it by and . Taking the curl of Darcy’s law twice removes the pressure: the vertical Darcy flux is driven only by horizontal buoyancy gradients. The heat balance couples back to through the base gradient .

Impermeable isothermal top and base, and sealed insulated sides, admit . With , substitution gives the growth rate above. The square box () has the smallest single-cell onset, .

Horton and Rogers (1945); Lapwood (1948); Nield and Bejan, Convection in Porous Media, section 6.2. Evaluated in convection_reference.py; no DES output or fitted parameter enters the reference.

Original reference.

Validity and limits​

Linear stability of the incompressible Boussinesq limit: small disturbances, constant properties, and a rigid matrix without pore-pressure feedback. DES keeps a small water storage; pressure diffuses about times faster than heat, so the incompressible reference applies. 3D cells, temperature-dependent viscosity and the Elder transient-plume problem are not yet verified.